Philosophy Journal Publishes Article Largely Authored by Claude
TL;DR. A philosophy journal knowingly published an academic article primarily generated by Anthropic's Claude LLM, with human oversight. - The University of Hong Kong professor Simon Goldstein provided the thesis and extensively edited Claude's output. - Publisher Wiley and the journal required disclosure of AI assistance but allowed its substantial use in drafting. - This signals an experiment in academic publishing as policies for AI-assisted scholarship evolve rapidly. - The journal's editor stated that official policies are still developing in response to such cases.
- Philosophy & Public Affairs published an article largely written by Anthropic's Claude LLM.
- Professor Simon Goldstein provided the thesis and acted as a 'heavy-handed supervisor' to Claude.
- Wiley's guidelines permit substantial AI use if disclosed, with the human author remaining responsible.
- The journal views this as an experiment, as formal policies on AI-assisted scholarship are still evolving.